Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Religion and Politics (just shoot me now please before I open my mouth)

Should religion matter in regard to presidential candidates? One person’s view is this…”no, I want competence first and a separation of church and state.”

I’m going to attempt to explain my thoughts on this subject. Most likely, you’re not going to find a lot of facts, dates, or name dropping here. You know me…this is just my opinion. And to qualify who “I” am, I will tell you that: I am an under 40 female, married with children, Christian who considers herself to be socially and culturally liberal and concerned above all things mostly with the rights of Americans as individuals and I try not to have myself associated too closely with one political group or religious group as you will find in knowing me that I live, work and play in the gray a lot and find that I cannot agree largely with any one group of people. When all people want to do is talk about the extreme…the religious right or the bleeding heart liberals…you may sometimes find me somewhere in between, but most likely you will find me off in a corner, talking about something of more importance.

What is religion? In the US, most think of religion as “church”. A place where people go who believe in Jesus and/or God. But in truth, religion is not church. It is a term to describe having a belief system. That belief system does not have to necessarily represent that of a God fearing group of people.

What is politics really? Simply put, politics is the exercise of public service. And “public” includes all people of the US. Those who believe in God and those who don’t.

We’ve been practicing, quite successfully I think, the separation of Church and State for a long time. This works well because one does not have control over the other. And why would we want one to have control over the other? Both religion and politics are complex and perplexing systems. But that does not, however, mean that one does not and should not have any interest in the other. Someone who considers themselves to have a belief system such as religion, probably believe that it is the fabric of their life.

But why are Americans paying so much attention to a political candidate’s religious affiliation? Psychologists tell us that one of our greatest human needs is to “belong”. When we are part of a belief system and we “belong”, we tend to want to vote for someone who “belongs” with us. I think its human nature. And I think that explains “why” it is happening if I had to make a very simple statement of “why”.

But the above question is “should” religion matter in regard to presidential candidates? Wow, okay, my answer…well, I would say it can matter. But I don’t think I can say it should matter. Not in the way of whether or not a candidate shares my religion it shouldn't but it should matter if a candidate has religion. It should matter if they have it because as I stated above, religion is a belief system and our idea of right and wrong need to come from somewhere. And its been coming from a belief system for a long time and it is a good foundation. I would say that it can carry some influence in my decision but at the same time, it can’t be the first and primary consideration in my vote. Why? I’m going to slip into the gray here…follow along…because…I am not my church. I am an American who loves God. And that is as simply as I can put it. I can’t let my church, the religious right, democrats or republicans or anyone for that matter speak for me. If a candidate has my same religious views, I may find that that candidate speaks to me because it is telling me that he has similar beliefs, but no one can speak for me. And although I have the same human needs as everyone else, I won’t vote for someone just to feel comfortable and to feel like I belong.

I also wish that politicians would stop lumping me in with the religious right just because I have a belief system. Most of us don't fall into that category. And our founding fathers, although Christian they were, were NOT the religious right.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm so glad we live near each other so we can go for coffee or something. Well said.

Rick said...

You know, I've been thinking about this. I have to be honest that I can help but let a canidates faith factor into my vote. It is part of who they are and who I am.

http://organizeddoodles.blogspot.com/

Elise said...

Many laws of most countries are based on religious morals.. "thou shalt not steal, kill, etc"

I think people have more faith in a political candidate if he has a belief system because it shows that he/ she has an understanding of basic morals... Its not necessarily true but it brings comfort to the public.

xx

Anonymous said...

Saying one is a christian does not make one a christian or for that matter , a person of faith - it is actiosn that mean more. The curetn occupant of the White House claims to be one but acts not as one...when I view the candidates for Prez, I must remember Jesus talking about not trusting those who proclaim their faith on the corners of streets.

Anonymous said...

The Ghost is right, however, I must also look at what dfines a person of faith and does it depend on the faith - I know many Muslims who are devout in their faith and do not condone the rape of that religion by extremists - in the same vein, I know many CHristians that do not condone the Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson's who warp christianity. So when I see the pandering and NEED to state how religious they are, I immediately question WHY IT IS NECESSARY FOR THEM TO SAY IT, if they are not just trying for votes...

Michelle Hix said...

To Christian Mother

I think you and I are on the same page...not sure. I don't think our founding fathers, despite being "Christian" would put themselves in the same category as the heads of our country today. There's a big difference.

Michelle Hix said...

Tom
I personally don't care if they shout it from a mountain top. It all depends to me on "why" they are proclaiming it. If it's to get votes and only to get votes, then their motive is obviously messed up. And yes, that is happening and has been happening for the last couple of presidential elections in the US. In addition, the line is becoming a bit blurred where church entities are backing a candidate and federal law prohibits this.

Michelle Hix said...

Something I have a problem with is this: When a Christian religious extremist does something and people turn to me and say "well, you are a Christian, you must agree with what they did right." People are going to call themselves Christians who aren't Christians. Christians who behave like Christians are also going to make mistakes like Christians do. But can we forget about the labels? Why the labels? Don't put your label on me...I'm just talking outloud here...anybody listening??? ha ha

Elise said...

Faith is a very personal thing. Extremists using faith as an excuse to voice their personl opinions are complete hypocrites. I don't think that an opinion of a Christian person represents all Chritians opinions and it shouldn't be percieved that way. The same goes for other faiths...

Cocaine Princess said...

Everyone is free to worship whomever they please. What I have a problem with is when they enforce their beliefs on others which causes problems. For example, I live in Canada and it's regarded as a multi-cultural society. Last year a judge removed the Christmas tree from the foyer of the court house because she thought it would be offensive to other faiths. You wouldn't believe the controversy this started, it went for days and days, people demanded the tree be put back up! The Premier intervened and ordered the tree be put back up. He stated 'this is Canada and Canadians celebrate the birth of Christ.' I know I went off topic kind of but I know where you're coming from. Have a Merry Christmas !!
XOXOXOXO,
Cocaine Princess